Gemstones Season 1 Memes: Kelvin bottoms, Gideon falls in love, and Keefe checks for semen loads
Gemstones Season 1 Finale: Judy and Kelvin begin to heal, Scotty joins the family, and we say goodbye with some random dicks
Back in Freeman's Gap : Church. In his sermon, Eli describes his visit to Aimee-Leigh's childhood home, where he interacted with her spirit. Cut to a flashback of the siblings collecting the money that Baby Billy and Tiffany stole from Scotty's van.
Rev. Seasons is redeemed: Cut to a flashback of Rev. Seasons (Dermot Mulroney) working in a hardware store (Baptist churches are autonomous, so if one closes you don't automatically get placed elsewhere). Eli offers him a job as pastor of the satellite church that Baby Billy abandoned. Rev. Seasons was a secondary Big Bad, but Eli stole his flock, so we are not sure who needs forgiveness more.
"If you're not rooting for your enemy's salvation, you are not in line with what the Spirit wants." Shots of Dot Nancy and her parents, BJ, Keefe (working security again), Martin's wife, a couple I don't recognize, and Jesse's crew (Matthew, Gregory, and Levi). Notice that BJ and Keefe are linked, structurally presented as the partners of Judy and Kelvin. They won't begin sitting together until Season 3.
Scotty is redeemed: "Aimee-Leigh knew this. That's why she wanted to help, no matter what." Shot of the spirit of Aimee-Leigh sitting in the congregation, glowing in ethereal light, with Scotty beside her.
Maybe, in spite of his machinations, posturing, criticism, and threats, in spite of the hints of abuse, this is what Scotty wanted all along. After all, the goal of the two schemes was to draw Gideon away from his family so they could spend their lives together. Maybe he couldn't admit it to himself, so it came out in random bursts, like calling Gideon "cute," taking him out on dates, and finally admitting, just before his death, that "you broke my heart." Aimee Leigh helped him understand what he needed, what he wanted, and she has made him a Gemstone.
Baby Billy grifts: "For when you forgive other people when they sin against you, your Heavenly Father will forgive you." Cut to Baby Billy and Tiffany selling their new gimmick, pictures of his trip to heaven. I guess they haven't been redeemed yet.
Kelvin and Judy start to heal: "How we navigate this life, and each other, is what defines us, and what leads us on the path to healing." Cut to Judy and Kelvin in makeup, getting ready to perform, smiling.
Before this season, the siblings spend their lives crippled by the traumas of their past. Unable to believe that they were worthy of being loved, they sabotaged every potential relationship, Judy by defining herself soley as a sexual being, and Kelvin by denying that he was a sexual being at all. In this season they found partners who loved them in spite of their spitefulness, selfishness, and general craziness, in spite of Judy's obsession with the phallus and Kelvin's fear of it. Forgiven, redeemed, they have started on the road to healing.
The conclusion and cocks after the break
Gemstones Episode 1.9: Kelvin goes dark, Keefe goes down, and Captain America saves the day. With a Haitian dick bonus.
Jesus never dated much: Sibling movie night at Kelvin's house ((notice the K and the arcade game behind their couch). They're watching The Neverending Story., at the scene where Artax horse/companion of the hero Atreyu (Noah Hathaway), is literally consumed by his sadness, sinking to his death. Atreyu yells: "Fight against the sadness. You have to try. You have to care. You're my friend. I love you." Suddenly Kelvin bursts into tears
In the movie, the Childlike Empress is sick, thus allowing the Darkness (hopelessmess, despair) to slowly devour the Kingdom of Fantasia. Young hero Atreyu is looking for a cure to save Fantasia, but he is unable to save his horse/friend Artax. Maybe Kelvin is thinking of how he couldn't save Keefe from his own Sadness: "My emotions are all over the place. I feel like I'm coming unhinged." The siblings ignore him, so he repeats: I'm in emotional turmoil, dealing with some very painful questions about myself."
"For real?" Jesse immediately becomes serious. Remember, he thinks that Kelvin is gay, but in denial. Is he ready to come out?
Nope. "I've always felt like, maybe, I'm Him." He's always felt like he is Jesus? Say what? Dude, that's full-blown psychosis.
Actually, many cult leaders claim to be Jesus. Wikipedia lists 40 in the 20th and 21st centuries alone, including Jim Jones, Marshall Applewhite, Charles Manson, Shoko Asahara, David Koresh. It doesn't usually end well.
Kevin's reasons: we both care about people; people like us, and want to follow us. Wait -- you just have one follower, Keefe, and he's not worshipping you. He gets on his knees for another reason entirely.
Plus: "(Jesus) didn't date much, didn't have the urge or the need to. That's me for days." Fans sometimes use this line to argue that Kelvin is asexual, not experiencing desire for anyone, but in a heteronormative society, surely he means "urge or need to date women." I'm sticking with the theory that Kelvin was out there breaking his celibacy promise, shoving his cock through the glory holes at Club Sinister every night, and feeling guilty about it the next morning.
Jesse, aware of another reason for Kelvin's lack of interest in women, assures him that he's not Jesus, but "that doesn't mean you're not a decent man." Notice that he uses the term "man," signifying that Kelvin is grown-up, an adult, regardless of his sexual identity.
But Kelvin doesn't buy it. Another voice is telling him, "If you can't be him, maybe you can be me...Satan." We know from the Satanic Sweep and the Club Sinister rescue that, in Kelvin's eyes, Satan is all about sex, or sex is all about Satan. The only way he can explain his homoerotic desire, and maybe his homoerotic intimacy, is by fashioning himself "the Dark Lord of the family." After all of this, how did fans continue to argue that Kelvin was straight?
He's very tired -- he hasn't been sleeping well lately. Because he usually shares his bed with Keefe? And he misses Mama, who used to tell him that everything's gonna be ok. She's gone, so Jesse and Judy step up: "Everything's gonna be ok. You'll get it figured out." It's not hard to figure out, Dude. Lots of people are gay.
Before we continue, some bonus Haitian guys.
I think he's from Jamaica
Kelvin corrects her: "Ok, no, he's not my boyfriend. We're just a couple dudes who like to hang out. Why?" He's being awfully nonchalant -- compare Season 3, where "rumors swirling around" drive him into a panic. He's already the Dark Lord, a being infused by homoerotic desire, so why get upset over a simple mistake?
Fans who insist that "Kelvin is straight!" often point to this statement, but maybe they're not "boyfriends," partners in a caring, emotionally-fulfilling relationship. Kelvin believes that Satan is all about sex, not love, so whatever he feels for Keefe -- whatever he does with Keefe -- must be driven solely by lust.
More after the break
Gemstones Episode 1.8: Kelvin's testicles, Jesse's butt, and ancient Philistine penises. WIth testicular bonus
Denim brings lunch: We cut to scenes where Baby Billy and Tiffany leave town with the offering money, Eli worries that the whole enterprise is corrupt, and Jesse apologizes to Gideon for pushing him away and starting the whole mess. Eli admits, for the only time in the series, that the church's finances are not entirely above-board.
He refuses to take Judy back, so she storms into the parking lot and starts destroying cars, finally getting arrested.
Hemorrhoids and Testicular Tumors: Keefe is swimming while Kelvin tries not to look at the body that is giving him so many unwelcome desires. He wants to know how he can rid the world of darkness, when he's surrounded by it: his mother died, Eli was assaulted, the church was robbed. Not to mention Jesse committing assault and probably vehicular homicide. He concludes that God is punishing the family for "not being who we say we are."
Left: Kelvin's testicles.
But Kelvin had nothing to do with those things. He was in the car with his siblings when they ran over the blackmailers, but he didn't assault anyone. At most he failed to tell anyone. How does "not being who we say we are" apply to him? Unless he is talking about being gay.
"Don't you think God is being a little harsh?" Keefe asks. We all wear masks; we hide things even from ourselves.
Kelvin laugh/cries and says "I think we're getting off easy...when the Philistines stole the Ark of the Covenant, God punished them with hemorhhoids and testicle tumors."
He's referring to an obscure story in 1 Samuel 4-5, where the Philistine thieves were punished with opalim. The King James Bible translates the Hebrew word as "emeroids" (now "hemorrhoids") and the NIV as "tumors." An article in Biblical Archaeology Review points out the importance of penises in Philistine art, and suggests "flaccid penises." No one mentions testicles; apparently Kelvin invented it, to correspond to the glimpse of Keefe's testicle that began his recognition of his homoerotic desire.Next: "You should go, Keefe." Keefe doesn't understand: "You want me to make a store run?" Kelvin becomes angrier and angrier: "Go. Leave. Get out. I am no longer fit to lead you!"
Kelvin scratches his butt as he says this. Apparently he has hemorrhoids, and thinks that God is punishing him -- an ironic punishment for having anal sex? Will testicular tumors come next?
Keefe disagrees: "There's no one more worthy than you."
"Get the fuck out of here! Now! Do I need to call security, motherfucker?" This is shockingly aggressive. Besides, if Keefe has been living there for several months, you have to give him 30 days notice.
Keefe wades away, holding his swimsuit like he held his shirt during the mushroom head scene. The intimacy he enjoyed that night has been revoked. Kelvin falls into the pool and screams and cries.
Gemstones Episode 1.6 : Kelvin sees Keefe's cock, and gets a big head. Sounds like a fun evening. With bonus Kenyan guys.
Title: "Now the sons of Eli were worthless men." From 1 Samuel 2:12. Eli was a high priest during the era of the Judges. His two sons did not perform the sacrifices properly, and had illicit sexual relations, so the Lord punished Eli by killing them. Uh-oh, Jesse and Kelvin are doomed.
Keefe's Mushroom Head: After their Friday night encounter with the blackmailers, Jesse has their van towed to Kelvin's garage, talks to Kelvin, then fetches Judy. Jesse is wearing the same clothes, but Kelvin has changed out of his Faith Factory t-shirt.
As they are talking, Keefe comes out of the house, wearing only a shirt and socks, eating cheese. "What's going on?" he asks.
Jesse: "Sickening!"; Judy: "Cool mushroom tip"; Kelvin: "That shirt's not as long as you think, Bud. Just go back inside." We see his dick peeking out from below his shirt, and then his butt as he turns around.
Structurally, this seems to be a joke on Keefe being drug-addled, combined with a view of his cock and butt that leads us to ask "are they or aren't they." But in- universe, it becomes much more significant.
First, notice that just a few episodes ago, Kelvin was terrified by the sight of Keefe's testicle. Now he is embarrassed but not alarmed. He is used to seeing Keefe naked.
Second, why is Keefe wearing only a shirt and socks? Was he in bed? No -- when you get dressed, you put on your pants first. Getting ready for bed? No, when you get undressed, you take off your shirt first.
"Go suck your Satanic boyfriend Keefe."
A likely scenario: After the Club Sinister rescue, the guys drop Dot off, then go home and change clothes. Some time later, Keefe decides to move forward with the relationship that Kelvin has been suggesting, Since he rejected a bj offer earlier, it makes sense that he would want to start with a bj. He takes his pants off, and his shoes have to come off, too. Kelvin is so overcome by passion that he doesn't have time to take his clothes off -- he just drops to his knees.
As they are getting busy, there's a knock on the door. Keefe waits for Kelvin to return, gets bored, goes to the kitchen, gets some cheese. Then he hears everyone talking and, assuming that his shirt is long enough to cover his dick, investigates.
It makes structural sense: Keefe looks for love in Episode 1.4, rejects the Satanists to follow Kelvin, and ends up in Kelvin's bed. If Kelvin's "celibacy promise" was real, tonight he broke it, thus making his later despair more realistic. And it would lead into the isolation tank rescue.
Saturday or Sunday: Rev. Seasons announces that his church is closing due to losing members to the Baby Billy's Locust Grove church. We cut to Eli, Baby Billy/Tiffany, and BJ/Judy playing golf. Wait -- shouldn't they be in church? Or is this Sunday afternoon?
"This isn't normal": Meanwhile, at Jesse and Amber's house, Gideon comes down to breakfast with a black eye. His parents are upset, but they don't make the connection to the car chase last night. So it's Saturday morning? Was the Rev. Season scene a flashback?
These timeline inconsistencies are annoying. Let's just think about Keefe's cock again.
More about Keefe's Cock: Kelvin's garage, several days later (queer code: there's a neon picture of a flexing bicep on the wall).
They are very rude: Since the van is gone, Scotty has to live in a tent. Why doesn't Gideon spring for a cheap hotel? Gideon tries to help him set it up, but he goes dark again: "I'm tired of this shit, and I'm tired of your fucking family! They are very rude people!" But at least he looks hot in a black vest with no shirt.
"The van in my uncle's garage," Gideon tells him. Completely ransacked, with all of Scotty's stuff taken. Scotty is irate: he needed that stuff!
Cut to Jesse and Kelvin informing the crew that they have the van. Inside they found a sleeping bag, tongs, a copy of L. Ron Hubbard's Dianetics (so Scotty is a Scientologist?), some potato chips, some beans, soiled Q-Tips, and yellow, crusty paper towels. Conclusion: the blackmailers are "fucking amateurs."
Suddenly all of them get a phone call from Scotty. He wants his van and his stuff back, or "I'm a fuck your life in the ass." I'm surprised no one riffed on that. "I'm a release the video."
Back at the campsite, Scotty and Gideon clasp hands.
Jesse doesn't think he has the video, and tells him to fuck off.
More after the break
Blair's Hot/Hung Photos, Part 2: Fitness model, stripper, deputy. Only his abs and dick stay the same
This is a collection of hot/hung and humorous photos of Blair Jackson, the actor/model who became Kelvin's nemesis in Righteous Gemstones Episode 1.4, "Wicked Lips."
Gemstones Episode 1.4: Keefe looks for love in a sports bar, Gideon and Scotty date, and Kelvin meets a girl. Plus Blair Jackson and Daedalus dicks
Gemstones Episode 1.3: Kelvin outs himself, Baby Billy gets naked, and Scotty shoves his wiener into Gideon's face.. With some bonus wieners.
He stands -- a huge cock fills the screen! Objectively it's not very big, but we've never seen a close-up of a cock in any tv show before, and rarely anything at all, so it is startling and highly erotic, underscoring that Baby Billy is a creature of prodigious sexual appetite.
The Satellite Church: Judy, BJ, and Kelvin are scoping out the dying shopping mall where they opened the satellite church: "All around America, capitalism is dying," Kelvin points out. "That's when we step in." He will never display this insightful knowledge of economics, or anything other than muscles, again.
Queer code: First Kelvin does a little femme flutter and hand-on-waist. Then a hot girl walks past: an opportunity for him to demonstrate that he is heterosexual with a double-take? No,he looks the other way.
Baby Billy is greeting the congregants in front of gigantic photos of himself and Kelvin. Why Kelvin, in particular? Maybe to indicate that they're both outsiders, struggling to be taken seriously by the family. Or because they both have huge cocks.
As Baby Billy begins the service, the siblings watch from offstage. Gideon tunes up his guitar. Judy comments that he's "looking tasty. Staying in shape." Kelvin agrees; "He is. That's showbiz, right? You to to keep a tight physique." You just outed yourself to your sister, Kelv Baby.
Jesse disagrees: lots of people who work behind the scenes are "fat as fuck,." But, Kelvin insists, if you want to be a star, you have to be a "specimen...a straight unit." According to the Urban Dictionary, a "straight unit" is a guy who is tall, strong, muscular, and well-hung. How much farther out can Kelvin get?
Afterwards the siblings meet Tiffany. They disapprove of her countrified lack of refinement, her teeth, and her insistance that they call her Aunt Tiffany, even though she is younger than
My Wiener in Your Face: That night, while Jesse and Amber discuss whether Gideon is Saul or Paul (before or after finding Jesus), Gideon answers the question for us: he goes through his parents' stuff, looking up the value of things he could steal and sell, now that the blackmail plot has fallen through. Their nightstand, for instance, cost $2700.
Meanwhile, at the campground where Scotty is staying, he stumbles out of the van and urinates in front of everyone. A guy protests "Don't nobody want to see that penis!" Scotty counters: "Then quit lookin' at it." A reference to Scotty liking guys to appreciate his penis?
Gideon brings him the list of stuff to steal, but Scottyy tears it up: he doesn't want furniture and jewelry, he wants money. He begins to erupt, but Gideon assures him: "I can get it, but my parents don't trust me yet. Be patient."
To demonstrate how unhinged he is, Scotty puts a cigarette out on his tongue and waves a wiener on a wire in front of Gideon's face. This is, of course, a symbolic threat of sexual assault.
Gemstones Episode 1.1: Kelvin is in love with a Goth boy, and Gideon with the Devil. Plus a bisexual orgy, nude Chengdu dudes, and Scott Wolfe's bulge
In the new year, let's go back to the beginning, or at least to 2019, for Righteous Gemstones Episode 1.1
Kelvin and the Vampire: Kelvin walks into his game room, and starts sorting his mail. Suddenly a half-naked man appears in the doorway, lowering from a sit-up bench like a vampire rising from his coffin -- next to an Egyptian mummy case. This is the Land of the Dead.
Kelvin: "You scared the bullcrud out of me!"
Left: At the gym
He continues to criticize Jesse for not "letting me be me."
Is this a reference to Kelvin being gay? Will he come out during this season, or is he already out?
After a bro fist-bump, Kelvin asks (his friend has not yet been named, but we'll call him Keefe) how the housesitting went.
It went fine. Keefe slept in Kelvin's room one night, "But it felt odd, so I slept the rest of the time here on the couch." The huge house must have a dozen guest rooms. Why the couch?
Kelvin: "Hey, man, you do not need to feel odd sleeping in my bed. I told you you could." Is he easing Keefe into the idea of sleeping with him, so sex can happen by "accident"?
Keefe didn't like being in Kelvin's room: "The energy in there is just unsettling. It's lonely" Very insightful. He can sense Kelvin's loneliness. There's no one in his life, no friends, no romantic partner. He doesn't realize it yet, but he is, in the words of Dag Hammarskjold, "screaming for love." .
Kelvin thanks him for looking after the place: "Home-run friendship." Keefe is appreciative: "I know not everybody wanted me here." House-sitting? Why would the family care?
Timeline problem: Keefe was a Satanist before he and Kelvin met. Maybe Kelvin even brought him to Christ. How long have they known each other? In a future episode, Keefe's Satanist friends wonder why he hasn't been around lately, so just a few weeks. But there's a faded 666 tattoo on Keefe's chest. Laser tattoo removal takes 6-10 sessions, scheduled 6-8 weeks apart. Did Keefe start the removal long before he met Kelvin, or did the writers goof? .
Keefe decides to return to his apartment: "I'm pretty bushed. Gonna go soak in a tub. " It's the middle of the day! You haven't seen your friend in a week or so. Why don't you want to stick around? Are you worried about things heading in a direction you're not ready for?
"No, man!" Kelvin pleads. "Let's stay up late, play some video games, smash some Pixie Sticks." Staying up past your bedtime? Eating sugar? Are you planning a sexual encounter or a junior high sleepover?
Keefe refuses politely. "That sounds good, but I really need a soak...I like to turn it up real hot." A sexual double-entendre. Keefe is overtly excluding Kelvin from his erotic life, saying "I'm going to have sex, but you're not invited."
Kelvin asks for a hug. Keefe reluctantly approaches. "So happy you're home," he whispers.
Kelvin seems to be pushing for a sexual relationship, but Keefe isn't sure. He's been saved (converted) for only a few weeks. He might find Kelvin attractive, but the power differential is enormous, and maybe he's been abused by clergy before. It's best to reject overtures that sound too sexual, play it cool, and see what happens.
This has been a lot to digest. Who would expect a show from Danny McBride, producer of Vice Principals and Eastbound & Down, would have a major gay character? And played by Adam Devine, who played a hetero-horny dudebro on Workaholics and fell in love with a girl in Modern Family?
But wait a minute: if you want Kelvin to be gay, why not say so? Say the word "gay," or have the guys kiss. Other tv shows with gay characters do the word or the kiss in the first scene. If you don't, the "they can't be gay!" camp is going to argue and argue to the bitter end.
Plus, in an interview during Season 2, Adam envisions that in ten years, Kelvin will be married to a woman. In another interview, he says that he wants to play a gay guy who doesn't go through a long, painful coming-out process, but has regular adventures with his boyfriend. It sounds very much like he perceives his character as straight. Or is he dissimulating to keep viewers guessing?
Things are going to get even crazier after the break
Gemstones Season 2 Finale: The Godfather, Butch and Sundance, random nude dudes, and "My love for you wil never die"
The series finales on The Righteous Gemstones are meant to tie up any remaining loose ends and say goodbye to the characters, so we should expect little or no plot development, just a lot of hugging: everyone who has had lost, frayed, or troubled relationships during the season, lovers, friends, parents and children, siblings, will be reconciled.
Hold on tight to the one you love the most: A blackened stage. Suddenly a spotlight on Jesse. He begins the country-western song "Some Broken Hearts Never Mend," by Don Williams. Then Kelvin, lying on a platform, raising a finger to Heaven. Then Judy and the choir, as she walks up stage. Then all three siblings together.
Coffee black, cigarettes. Start the day like all the rest.
First thing every moning that I do, is start missing you.
Some broken hearts never mend. Some memories never end.
Some tears will never dry. My love for you will never die.
Except this song is not about lost love, it's about mended hearts. You're supposed to look at or point to a loved one. Kelvin starts out by pointing at audience stage left, obviously at Keefe, who points to himself and then back. My love for you will never die,
BJ waves, presumably at Judy. Cut to Amber and the kids; then Baby Billy, Tiffany, and the baby; he looks back at Harmon, his no-longer estranged son; and finally Eli looks out at the audience.
In the middle of love's embrace: Flashback to the Alaska Commercial Company, a grocery store chain with 33 locations in Alaska, mostly in rural areas. The Lissons, in hiding after their murders and attempts, are buying -- coffee to go? Martin has them under surveillance
Back in church, Eli looks at the band as the siblings sing the second verse together. Then Jesse and Kelvin, looking up to heaven.
Rendezvous in the night.
In the middle of love's embrace, I see your face
Wait -- they see God while their partners Amber and Keefe are going downtown? Makes sense.
Cut to the Lissons in their cabin, watching Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid, where the gay-subtext bank robbers, played by Robert Redford, top photo, and Paul Newman, left, are trapped, with no escape, so they go out shooting.
Some broken hearts never mend. Some memories never end.
Some tears will never dry. My love for you will never die.
The Cycle Ninjas: Cycle Ninjas on glittering metallic snowmobiles zoom through the woods.
The First Chorus: The congregation rises to sing the chorus.
We see Chad and his wife, who have been having marital problems since Season 1; Martin and his often seen, never-named wife; Judy and BJ; Junior and Tan Man, Baby Billy and Tiffany, Amber and the kids. Then the siblings again. Wait, I thought the Tan Man was just Junior's assistant. Is there a gay relationship going on back in Memphis?
In the flashback, the Lissons get out their guns and tell each other that God believes in them: "God will see us through, for we are the Chosen." Where on Earth did Lyle get that idea?
More broken hearts after the break








































