Just putting the reviews back into their proper sequence.
Keefe's Mushroom Head: After their Friday night encounter with the blackmailers, Jesse has their van towed to Kelvin's garage, talks to Kelvin, then fetches Judy. Jesse is wearing the same clothes, but Kelvin has changed out of his Faith Factory t-shirt.
As they are talking, Keefe comes out of the house, wearing only a shirt and socks, eating cheese. "What's going on?" he asks.
Jesse: "Sickening!"; Judy: "Cool mushroom tip"; Kelvin: "That shirt's not as long as you think, Bud. Just go back inside." We see his dick peeking out from below his shirt, and then his butt as he turns around.
Structurally, this seems to be a joke on Keefe being drug-addled, combined with a view of his cock and butt that leads us to ask "are they or aren't they." But in- universe, it becomes much more significant.
First, notice that just a few episodes ago, Kelvin was terrified by the sight of Keefe's testicle. Now he is embarrassed but not alarmed. He is used to seeing Keefe naked.
Second, why is Keefe wearing only a shirt and socks? Was he in bed? No -- when you get dressed, you put on your pants first. Getting ready for bed? No, when you get undressed, you take off your shirt first.
"Go suck your Satanic boyfriend Keefe."
A likely scenario: After the Club Sinister rescue, the guys drop Dot off, then go home and change clothes. Some time later, Keefe decides to move forward with the relationship that Kelvin has been suggesting, Since he rejected a bj offer earlier, it makes sense that he would want to start with a bj. He takes his pants off, and his shoes have to come off, too. Kelvin is so overcome by passion that he doesn't have time to take his clothes off -- he just drops to his knees.
As they are getting busy, there's a knock on the door. Keefe waits for Kelvin to return, gets bored, goes to the kitchen, gets some cheese. Then he hears everyone talking and, assuming that his shirt is long enough to cover his dick, investigates.
It makes structural sense: Keefe looks for love in Episode 1.4, rejects the Satanists to follow Kelvin, and ends up in Kelvin's bed. If Kelvin's "celibacy promise" was real, tonight he broke it, thus making his later despair more realistic. And it would lead into the isolation tank rescue.
Saturday or Sunday: Rev. Seasons announces that his church is closing due to losing members to the Baby Billy's Locust Grove church. We cut to Eli, Baby Billy/Tiffany, and BJ/Judy playing golf. Wait -- shouldn't they be in church? Or is this Sunday afternoon?
"This isn't normal": Meanwhile, at Jesse and Amber's house, Gideon comes down to breakfast with a black eye. His parents are upset, but they don't make the connection to the car chase last night. So it's Saturday morning? Was the Rev. Season scene a flashback?
These timeline inconsistencies are annoying. Let's just think about Keefe's cock again. A nice view after the break. Warning: explicit.