But he first made an impression on gay teens with Far from Home: The Adventures of Yellow Dog (1995), where his Angus is lost in the Canadian wilderness with a dog named Yellow, fights for survival, and takes his shirt off, revealing a hard, firm but not muscular chest.
Unfortunately, Jesse's later projects involved a lot of girls.
In Clockstoppers (2002), Jesse and The Girl find a device that allows them to move super-fast, in effect stopping time.
But his darkly handsome teen idol face was sure to elicit swoons from gay teens.
The thriller Swimfan (2002) is about a psychotic girl who stalks Jesse, a high school swimmer. Though he is heterosexual, the disdain he feels as the girl becomes more and more insistent in her desire to be with him can be read as a gay subtext. And fans got to see Jesse in a revealing swimsuit.
Some buddy bonding: his character Balthazar likes Romeo (Leonardo DiCaprio) in Romeo+Juliet (1996).
After playing a gay hustler in Speedway Junky (1999), with Jonathan Taylor Thomas as his bisexual colleague, Jesse turned down a gay role in The Rule of Attraction (2002). Back then guys worried that playing gay would destroy their career.
More after the break